Protestant and Catholic Unite and Fight

by red dub Sat Jun 15, 2002 14:07

I AM NOT, REPEAT NOT, IN THE SWP.

I am just pissed off that a serious issue has been hijacked into anti-swp crap as as so much else on indymedia. the site is falling apart.

of course he is free to express his opinion. he is wrong though.

by pissed off Fri Jun 14, 2002 16:30

swp reaction to criticism: fascistic abuse and intimidation. you're a wanker, fuck off...

leave myles alone.
he is free to express his opinions.

by red dub Fri Jun 14, 2002 15:07

Is that it? Sloganeering?

So you have no actual disagreement with the original post. So what is the point of all this?

And 'your' sloganeering?

Its the world against poor old Myles!

Ayone got anything helpful to contribute?

by Myles Fri Jun 14, 2002 14:45

1 I'm not a wanker
2 I repeat, your sloganeering is simplistic and patronising

by red dub Thu Jun 13, 2002 21:09

Myles, you are a wanker.

There is some of the worst rioting in thrity years happening in Belfast and it is spreading. The SWP are trying to agitate class unity in face of IRA/UVF sectarianism. What do you do? Criticise them because they are the SWP. No analysis or alternatives.

There is a war on. Our living standards and civil liberties are under attack. The Palestinaians are getting slaughtered. What is your contribution?SWP bashing. The Irish left is starting to get serious and organised. You are an irrelevance and rather than this being a thread of positive anti-bigoted ideas, we are dragged down to this.

Myles is someone who is so beaten and bitter about his own politics, the best he can do is attack some positive left wing ideas. You might disagree with the SWP's methods, but what could you possibly find wrong with the post? Be helpful on this or fuck off. Its too serious an issue for your delusional ravings.

He cannot be for real.

by Whatever Thu Jun 13, 2002 10:13

Speaking of articulating thoughts clearly, Myles, the only criticism you have made about this article is that it is from a SWP member. We understand you have a problem with that but do you have a problem with any of the content of the original post. Be coherent now...

by myles Wed Jun 12, 2002 23:43

what do you mean by troll? can't you articulate
your thoughts a bit more coherently?

by pizt off Tue Jun 11, 2002 23:57

Myles is mostly correct, the swmmers love issuing (and screaming) simplistic slogans that actually mean very little if subjected to any serious scrutiny. Half baked sloganeering such as 'Catholic and Protestant workers unite and fight' is actually insulting and patronising to workers from both communities. However it saves having to do a serious analysis and sounds a bit lefty, and it wont frighten off middle class labour and fine geal members, who the swm hope to recruit.

by Anarcho-taigh Tue Jun 11, 2002 18:02

Aye, ok. I was there.And yes, it was great to see a timy general strike and people saw it as effective, at least in my workplace ( bus station). But mate, it was months ago and I think you should have open the debate earlier since you seem to be so involved in the issue ( well, issue is not really the right word).
Oh, and you forgot to mention prod kids who got stuff thrown at them while they were going to school on the Limestone Rd, between Newington St and Tiger Bay...and prod workers ( marks&spencer) being approched by the IRSP...the fear prods feel might seem weird and irrelevant but it is this feeling that the loyalists use: fear of your neighbours and fear of your "protectors" as well. I don't try to make prods being poor little victims but it is difficult for them to see an alternative to their daily situation. And no, they don't like the english, this is not the point ( some even dislike the queen, believe it or not). Enough with silly cliches.
One last word: this is so stupid to start again an argument against the SWP. I dislike them but I'd rather try to get some stuff going on along with them and even the SP rather than SF and the PUP...at least on this issue.

by Myles Tue Jun 11, 2002 17:05

Is that all you can say? Come on, try to think a little bit harder.

by Myles Tue Jun 11, 2002 14:54

This statement is bloody patronizing and I'm free to say it.

by Kommy Tue Jun 11, 2002 14:26

I think that Dan has a good point here. Regardless of one's views of the SWP, Dan is making a very valid arguement. The workers from both sides of the sectarian divide should unite and demand and end to violence from both sides.
Whilst I do not agree with the methods of the SWP and will express such a view when I see evidence of those methods, it is pointless and even counterproductive to mock a decent statement from anyone.
If you've got criticisms, it gives them more weight if they're relevant to the points being expressed.

by Mc Meaner Tue Jun 11, 2002 09:23

to show some of englands-loyalist where the are at

by Komsomol Tue Jun 11, 2002 02:09 komsomol at swirve dot com

isnt it amazing how anything can be turned into a anti swp discussion on this website....

by hmm Mon Jun 10, 2002 23:33

Myles,
"can't cope with debate", debate would be your incisive 1st comment which said precisly what?

The man might be: right, wrong, misinformed or a fucking genius but it wasn't exactly productive on your part was it?

by Myles Mon Jun 10, 2002 18:14

Oh yes, I'm a tool ?!

How the SWP works and why they can't cope with debate:

A centralized authority hands down the gospel to their lesser cadre, who in turn hand down the gospel in a very patronizing way to that non-descript blob, "the masses".
Ordinary members dress up in a fashion reminiscent of the 1930s and do their best rendition of how they imagine "the masses" to eat, drink and feel. Unfortunately, on the rare occasions they mix with the masses, they look kind of lost.

by Myles Mon Jun 10, 2002 16:32

This is very subtle and useful stuff. I was particularly impressed by the originality
of the slogan. It really looks like you have found the way to unite the Northern Irish workers. The ruling classes are about to receive a major blow. Congratulations lads.

by Dan Buckley Mon Jun 10, 2002 14:51

By the way, in britain and the north the main fighters against privatisation are the postal workers. Thats why I mention them.
I was meant to put that in but absolutely forgot.