Don't Fence Us In, by Naomi Klein

Saturday October 05, 2002 16:19

by Naomi Klein

Naomi Klein Don't Fence Us In

When I first noticed that the image of the fence kept coming up in discussion, debates and in my own writing, it seemed significant to me. After all, the past decade of economic integration has been fuelled by promises of barriers coming down, of increased mobility and greater freedom. And yet 13 years after the celebrated collapse of the Berlin Wall, we are surrounded by fences yet again, cut off - from one another, from the earth and from our own ability to imagine that change is possible. The economic process that goes by the benign euphemism "globalisation" now reaches into every aspect of life, transforming every activity and natural resource into a measured and owned commodity. As the Hong Kong-based labour researcher Gerard Greenfield points out, the current stage of capitalism is not simply about trade in the traditional sense of selling more products across borders. It is also about feeding the market's insatiable need for growth by redefining as "products" entire sectors that were previously considered part of "the commons" and not for sale. The invading of the public by the private has reached into categories such as health and education, of course, but also ideas, genes, seeds, now purchased, patented and fenced off, as well as traditional aboriginal remedies, plants, water and even human stem cells. With copyright now the US's single largest export (more than manufactured goods or arms), international trade law must be understood not only as taking down selective barriers to trade but more accurately as a process that systematically puts up new barriers - around knowledge, technology and newly privatised resources. These Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights are what prevent farmers from replanting their Monsanto patented seeds and make it illegal for poor countries to manufacture cheaper generic drugs to get to their needy populations.

Globalisation is now on trial because on the other side of all these virtual fences are real people, shut out of schools, hospitals, workplaces, their own farms, homes and communities. Mass privatisation and deregulation have bred armies of locked-out people, whose services are no longer needed, whose lifestyles are written off as "backward", whose basic needs go unmet. These fences of social exclusion can discard an entire industry, and they can also write off an entire country, as has happened to Argentina. In the case of Africa, essentially an entire continent can find itself exiled to the global shadow world, off the map and off the news, appearing only during wartime when its citizens are looked on with suspicion as potential militia members, would-be terrorists or anti-American fanatics.

In fact, remarkably few of globalisation's fenced-out people turn to violence. Most simply move: from countryside to city, from country to country. And that's when they come face to face with distinctly unvirtual fences, the ones made of chain link and razor wire, reinforced with concrete and guarded with machine guns. Whenever I hear the phrase "free trade", I can't help picturing the caged factories I visited in the Philippines and Indonesia that are all surrounded by gates, watchtowers and soldiers - to keep the highly subsidised products from leaking out and the union organisers from getting in. I think, too, about a recent trip to the South Australian desert where I visited the infamous Woomera detention centre. At Woomera, hundreds of Afghan and Iraqi refugees, fleeing oppression and dictatorship in their own countries, are so desperate for the world to see what is going on behind the fence that they stage hunger strikes, jump off the roofs of their barracks, drink shampoo and sew their mouths shut.

read more at
http://www.guardian.co.uk/weekend/story/0,3605,803603,00.html

save preference

Comments (8 of 8)

if only we could put a nice face on capitalism - the world would be lovely

by if only we could put a nice face on capiatlsim

Sat Oct 05, 2002 16:28

lien hasn't got a klue

Sat Oct 05, 2002 16:29

klien hasn't got a klue

jon ronson's article about anthrax in the same issue of guardian weekend is much better. even if he is a grass.

God forbid!

by Noel

Sat Oct 05, 2002 16:34

Oh dear, Naomi Klein has sullied the purity of the left by daring to voice her own independent opinions from time to time! Call the thought police quick! She's not spouting the party line!

Can someone please point out to me what was so wrong with that article that it caused someone to say "she hasn't got a clue"?

The age of selfishness

by redjade

Sat Oct 05, 2002 19:38

I thought Martin Jacques' essay 'The age of selfishness' was a pretty interesting read this morning...

The age of selfishness
http://www.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,3604,805161,00.html

HI NAOMI! :-)

by iosaf mac diarmada & pals - reclaim the streets!

Sun Oct 06, 2002 14:43

ipsiphi23 at email dot com

Barcelona London Seattle Firenze Rome Berlin Helsinki

0034679708674

Hi Naomi!
we in the reclaim the streets! transnational family liked how you referred to us as
"a circus"...(which comes as if from nowhere).

with clowns, trapeze, jugglers, acrobats, media circus too, wombles, zapatistas, muppets, intellecuals with dogs on rope, and all the myriad people who make a movement.
You wrote a book which became part of a movement.
Quite right.
So we won´t let any one call you a lovely girl.
If they say "you sold out" we´ll say we liked the price you got for it.

keep on
naomi klein-ing

so that would mean :

by o as if = iosaf

Sun Oct 06, 2002 14:52

NO BORDERS.
http://www.keinmenschistillegal.org
http://www.noborders.org

it is a circus

by yeah

Sun Oct 06, 2002 20:07

RTS is a circus

it certainly isn't protest, therefore it must be a circus.

or at least an excuse to drink and smoke hash in front of the Garda without getting nabbed.

that's almost what the torento police said.

Sun Oct 06, 2002 21:04

An intercept of their radio gave us
"this is not a protest
repeat this is not a protest"
which is why we call the days
days of "celebration".
When we go out in carnival and reclaim the streets from logos capitalism cars and mediocre intellects.
We though remember these days for years.
And so too many others.
As Mr O' asif said we measure these days in gigabytes.

Number of comments per page

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Public Inquiry

Human Rights in Ireland

Don't Fence Us In, by Naomi Klein

Comments (8 of 8)