Tackle poverty to tackle educational disadvantage

national | consumer issues | news report

Wednesday July 09, 2008 10:42

by Gregor Kerr - WSM - Workers Solidarity

Scrap the 11+

The ongoing debate about how school pupils should transfer from primary to post-primary school in Northern Ireland raises fundamental questions about the type of society we want to live in.

The abolition of the Eleven Plus exam opened the possibility of establishing a fairer system than the one which had streamed children academically at the age of eleven, and one which was biased against children from poorer areas.

However it is clear that there are many in Northern Ireland for whom the prospect of fairness or equality is a scary concept. The extent to which those who wish to maintain the status quo have been successful is seen by the fact that they have been given huge media coverage, and have forced the Minister for Education Caitriona Ruane to introduce “a 3 year phased approach which will allow those schools which need time to adjust to the new system to use academic selection in a 3 year time bound limited manner…”

Buoyed by this success, grammar school principals are now attempting to introduce entrance tests for pupils to gain entry to their schools. This is nothing less than an attempt by them to maintain the current unfair system. In this regard they have received the support of the unionist parties. It is ironic that those who wish to maintain the current unfair system are using arguments about greater access to education for poor children to bolster their case. These arguments are totally spurious.

The Democratic Unionist Party argues, for example, that “Children do much less well in areas of social deprivation. It is important to have more young people from working class areas reaching grammar school and university. Only 1.8% of the male student population in Northern Ireland is from a Protestant working class background, but it is a process of academic selection that gives these young people the best opportunity of succeeding.” (www.dup.org.uk).

Surely however it would be more honest to argue that it is the lack of adequate funding for education at all levels that contributes to the fact that children from working class and poorer families do less well. And the process of academic selection at the age of 11 re-inforces and compounds that inequality. Inadequate funding of education combined with other social effects of poverty such as poor housing, poor diet, less access to the internet and to books, less time and space for parents to read to their children ensures that the cycle of disadvantage continues from generation to generation.

The maintaining of a system that brands huge numbers of children as failures by the age of 11 will do nothing to challenge this cycle of educational disadvantage. Those who really want to challenge it must be prepared to take on the issues of inadequate funding of education and must be willing to pursue policies which will tackle poverty head on.

Otherwise their statements about wanting to see ‘more young people from working class areas reaching university’ remain empty platitudes.

International studies all point to the fact that comprehensive education system whereby pupils of all abilities are educated together is the best way to raise education standards for all children.

save preference

Comments (2 of 2)

International Students Movement against the commercialisation of Education

by TS

Tue Jul 15, 2008 11:38

international.students.movement at gmail dot com

Students around the world are struggling against neoliberal reforms and the privatisation of education right now.

In 2007 alone students in over 30 countries staged partly massive protests against exploding tuition fees and turning of universities into business and corporate entities.
Check out this list of protests:
http://fading-hope.blog-city.com/international_student_protests_2007.htm

A truly democratic society needs emancipated citizens. And for that we need emancipating - instead of privatised and commercialised - education!
The following Group is for Free and Emancipating education worldwide. Join the “International Students Movement for Free and Emancipating Education”:
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=24722765003

If we unite in our struggle against the commercialisation of education, then we stand a chance!

PS: Join the international day of action against the commercialisation of education on 5th November! For more infos check out the facebook group~

CCFE (Ireland) is also fighting to end commercialism in Schools

by Mark C - Campaign for Commercial-Free Education - Personal Capacity

Tue Jul 15, 2008 13:40

The Irish Section of Campaign for Commercial-Free Education is also campaign against the neo-liberal policies that seek to gain (further) admittance into our schools.

If there's any teachers (or interested folks) reading this, perhaps you might consider joining us.

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Lockdown Skeptics

Voltaire Network

Tackle poverty to tackle educational disadvantage

Comments (2 of 2)