Neutral Ireland is dead and gone!

national | anti-war / imperialism | opinion/analysis

Sunday March 19, 2006 18:54

by Orlaith Farrell

orlaith.farrell at gmail dot com

Dublin

Irish neutrality is an area that has long been mis understood and mis-interpreted. The majority of people are very opinionated but know very little on the subject. Our Government has made decisions that will affect us without any referendum or regard for public opinion. But were we ever really neutral? The time has come for the Irish people to make a decision.

Last weekend as Bush landed in Shannon, aided by Garda, Army and Air Corps, his arrival was met with cries of outrage from the Irish people and yet again the old tired issue of our neutrality was raised. The day has long passed when Irish people can call themselves neutral, non-aligned perhaps, neutral no.

The reality of it is that all that is left of our supposed neutrality is deValera’s legacy of myth and mis-education. His refusal while in office to be perceived as a sub-ordinate of Britain was the birth place of Irish neutrality. The idea that our neutrality is grounded in our constitution is in fact a myth.

Ok so at least we can acknowledge DeValera for this one virtuous act for Ireland, not so, the United States have in fact been facilitated in Shannon since the second World War, granted with changes in media, DeValera was able to do it a little more covertly than Bertie but none the less, foreign troops in Shannon is not a new trend.

Ireland continues to hide behind an empty white flag in the face of European allegiance and our role as a US lap dog. As Condoleezza Rice fulfils her role as playground bully and Bertie Ahern gladly hands over his lunch money, we rely on myth of our constitutional neutrality to save us.

It has become the white flag that we wave when it suits us. We continue to facilitate ‘belligerents’ despite the requirements laid down by the Hague Convention to define neutrality and we wade deeper daily into European relationships. The truth of the matter is we have never adhered to neutral guidelines.

How can we continue to refer to ourselves as neutral?

When Ireland signed up to the European Union we automatically entered the transatlantic security setting. The small military neutrality we have maintained has been over shadowed by our strong political alliances; surely neutrality by definition is a total distinction from partnerships political or other?

Within Europe our neutrality is a very different entity. Here our government blurs the lines of our neutrality, but in the name of peace. On the basis of our neutrality Ireland has always declined to become a member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation. As we begin to re-evaluate our role is it out of a sense of responsibility that our Government join Partnership for Peace or due to a conscious decision to move toward NATO as its role in European security becomes more poignant?

Signing up to Partnership for Peace signifies ‘our commitment to the International Community to provide combined, co-operative efforts aimed at providing support to area’s in time of conflict’ as Declan Power Independent Security and Defence Analyst sees it. On the other hand Roger Cole from the Peace and Neutrality Alliance refers to these battle groups as ‘regiments of the emerging Empire’ in a speech laden with words such as evil, torture and Imperialist employing semantic tactics to deploy fear and ignorance.

As we slowly but surely merge with our non neutral European counterparts do these Alliances act as a stepping stone for full blown NATO membership? Should this be our time to finally make a decision, a referendum and the enshrinement of neutrality in our Constitution, or acknowledge our International responsibilities and immerse ourselves in the work of NATO?

The key role of NATO in European security has created both opportunities and dilemma’s for ‘former neutrals’ as we are now referred to by Stanley R. Sloan Senior Specialist in International Security Policy for Congress. The US no longer sees us as neutral how can we continue to kid ourselves?

The reality is we are having dinner with America, we’re in bed with the EU and our white flag is flying outside the front door. Ireland is the proverbial Ostrich, our head buried deep in a false sense of security that our so-called neutrality affords us. A mis-guided belief in a neutral Ireland is no form of defence. Is our vision of Ireland as an independent neutral state with the role of International peace-keeper, or is such a notion idealistic?

What George Bush’s arrival in Shannon signified last week was the time has come for real education on the subject and real decisions from the Irish people.

save preference

Comments (6 of 6)

Stop the Book of Honour

by Liam Obriain

Mon Mar 20, 2006 22:18

Donegal man Paddy Harte is to get every county in Ireland tio write a book which details the names of all those who died in World War One. Every county is to have its own Book of Honour . There was on Honour in the WW1,only SHAME and more SHAME, this man is how going to go into the schools,this is when he has to be STOPED.Our kids have to be protected,this man is saying there is Honour in that War, that war slaughtered the whole youth of europe at the time.Lets STOP this man.Any one who thinks, as I do and wants to have a go my No. is 074 97 30972.

Thy dead

by Honour

Mon Mar 20, 2006 23:08

The dead of the first world war and every other war should be honoured and remembered not ignored and Ireland shouldn't be neutral - neutrality is the refuge of the coward!
Anyway the Irish capitalist class have never been neutral they have always supported the interests of imperialism, so stop kidding yourself.

W W 1Shame

by Lian Obriain

Mon Mar 20, 2006 23:48

Look it toke more bravery to stand against the war than to go,the Irish people had their say in 1918,the vote was against the war, and imperialism ,now we must not move away from that.

Question about related link

by liny

Tue Mar 21, 2006 14:39

What's with the link to the club orange web site?

What about freedom of speech and association?

by john

Wed Mar 22, 2006 20:46

If Paddy Harte wants to write book and it sells well, give talks in schools and gets an audience from interested schoolchildren, that his private business, readers' private business and schoolchildrens' private business. If you dont want to commerate WWI or read his book or listen to his talks thats your private affair. Im not particularly interested either - I'll catch the movie.

the dead should be remembered

by rooster

Thu Mar 23, 2006 13:38

every country that sent young men into harms way remembers their war dead, Ireland is the only exception, thankfully over the last few years some politicians such as Mary Robinson have begun to correct this.

Number of comments per page

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Lockdown Skeptics

Voltaire Network

Neutral Ireland is dead and gone!

Comments (6 of 6)